Coatings & Corrosion
Flux marine 🔗
Skills Advanced: CAD (SolidWorks), Electrochemical Testing, Circuit Design, Node-RED, Raspberry Pi, Python, Coatings, Corrosion Protection
Objective: Identify potential root causes of and reduce corrosion on the Flux Marine outboard through a series of tests and create actionable recommendations for coatings and charging/operation protocols.
Flux began this test program after corrosion appeared on customer and test motors following the first current-gen motor deliveries. Flux hypothesized that the corrosion stemmed from three sources: electrical bonding across the system, stray current during operation and charging, and coating system degradation.
The six tests below evaluate that hypothesis, examine the corrosion resistance of various coating systems, and generate recommendations for charging and bonding procedures. I refined the test procedures, purchased materials, built all of the test setups, ran the tests, and reported on the findings.
Test Procedures
Flux developed six test procedures to isolate the contributing factors: system bonding (Test 1), anode protection and bonding (Tests 2–3), stray current during operation and charging (Tests 4A–4C), and coating performance under cyclic wet/dry and galvanic/crevice conditions (Tests 5–6).
Test 2 – Anode protection
Determine the effectiveness of the outboard anodes and whether they are over- or under-protecting the system.
Materials:
Flux Outboard
Bristol Harbor
Silver/silver-chloride (Ag/AgCl) reference electrode
DMM
Test 4A – DC Stray Current: Potential
Determine the existence of stray current from the outboard during charging and various operating states
Materials:
Flux Outboard with anodes removed
Bristol Harbor
silver/silver-chloride (Ag/AgCl) reference electrode
DMM
Test 4C – Stray Current: Galvanic Isolator
Determine the effectiveness of a galvanic isolator at reducing AC stray current during shore-power charging.
Materials
Flux outboard connected to shore power
110 V shore-power extension cable, spliced with an in-line galvanic isolator
DMM (AC current range)
Silver/silver-chloride Ag/AgCl reference electrode
Test 6 – Galvanic Crevice Cyclic Corrosion Test
A variation on Test 5, determine the optimal coating for the outboard's components, specifically the effect of intentional failure points on coating degradation
Materials
Plastic holding trays
3.5% salinity saltwater
Galvanic couple coupons
Coupon-hanging racks (wood, plastic hooks, wood screws)
Agitator pump
Pump control system (Raspberry Pi, relay, webcam)
Power supplies
M6 threaded rods, nuts, washers, ring terminals
M4 hardware
Waterproof epoxy
DMM
Test Automation
Tests 5 & 6 were automated via Node-Red. The pump for these tests ran on a wet/dry cycle for 100 cycles over the course of my internship.
Bonding and Anode Results: Tests 1–3
All three passed. Outboard electrical bonding is not the cause of the observed corrosion.
Test 1 Bonding: PASS
Resistance across the outboard is well within prescribed limits.
Test 2 Anode Protection: PASS
Noticeable variation between boats, but within the expected range.
Test 3 Anode Bonding: PASS
Anodes have a sufficient electrical connection to the outboard body.
Test 5 Results: Wet/Dry Cycling
Nine of ten coating systems came out of the test looking much as they went in.
Six Coatings Scored Perfectly
No blistering and no measurable undercutting on either ASTM D714 or D1654.
One Failure
The potentiostat measurements and applied ASTM standards were only enough to disqualify a single tested coating.
Conclusion
Cyclic saltwater alone is too mild to rank candidate coatings. The exposure needed a galvanic driving force to discriminate, which is what Test 6 provides.
Test 5 coupon (left) vs. Test 6 coupon (right) after the exposure
Galvanic isolator spliced into extension cord
Test 6 Results: Galvanic Coupling
Eight of the ten coating systems were visibly damaged under galvanic coupling.
Only 2 coatings survived galvanic exposure unscathed
DC Current data did not validate coating performance
Visual ASTM standards (D714, D1654) were the best metric for distinguishing coating performance
Overall, coatings performed significantly worse under the galvanic couple condition, meaning test 6 was the main factor in determining coating performance
The tests differentiated the candidate coatings into 4 performance tiers, with 20% of coatings performing in tier 1.
Tier 1: no blistering and no measurable creep on any coupon.
Tier 2: partial protection, with one coupon intact and one failure. < 3.5 mm creep.
Tier 3: dense blistering and 3.5-6 mm of consistent scribe creep.
Tier 4: worst creep and blistering in the test.
Findings
Coating Recommendation and Tradeoffs
Coating 3: primary
Zero creep, zero blistering on every coupon.
Immersion-rated splash-zone primer and spray-applied in a lab; not surprising that it performed very well in this test environment.
Coating 12: fallback for thinness
Significantly thinner than all other candidate coating systems while maintaining very good performance.
Does not require tolerance rework
An example of corrosive material loss
Test 1 – Outboard Bonding
Determine the effectiveness of bonding wires across the system and the electrical resistance throughout the outboard.
Materials:
Flux Outboard
Digital Multimeter (DMM)
Test 3 – Anode Bonding
Determine the effectiveness of the anode bonding of the outboard without uncoated contact pads below the anodes.
Materials:
Flux Outboard
Bristol Harbor
Silver/silver-chloride (Ag/AgCl) reference electrode
DMM
Alligator jumper wires
Protective anodes removed for stray current testing
Test 4B – DC Stray Current: Current
Determine the existence of stray current from the outboard during charging and various operating states
Materials:
Flux Outboard with anodes removed
Bristol Harbor
Silver/silver-chloride (Ag/AgCl) reference electrode
DMM
Alligator jumper wires
Graphite coupon
10 Ohm resistor
Test 5 – Wet/Dry Cycle Potentiodynamic Prohesion Test
Determine the optimal coating for the outboard's components, specifically the effect of intentional failure points on coating degradation
Materials
Plastic holding trays
3.5% salinity saltwater (simulated ocean water)
Test coupons with various coatings
Coupon-hanging racks (wood, plastic hooks, wood screws)
Agitator pump
Pump control system (Raspberry Pi, relay, webcam)
Power supplies
Small plastic tray
3D-printed electrode jig
Ag/AgCl reference electrode
Graphite counter electrode
Rodeostat potentiostat
M4 hardware
Waterproof epoxy
Why Does Test 6 Exist?
Test 6 better replicates the service conditions of components fastened with hardware made of a different metal. The difference in natural potentials between dissimilar metals creates a galvanic couple that drives faster corrosion.
Test 5
Test 6
Results
Stray Current Results: Tests 4A–4C
An in-line galvanic isolator cut AC stray current by >95% repeated across two swap cycles and reproduced on the NE XSF.
The trend held even when the boat was at 100% charge, indicating that the stray current is caused by the shore ground, not high current flow.
An isolator benefits the standard charging protocol.
4A and 4B were inconclusive but suggested that the Flux platform does not leak meaningful DC stray current under operation.
Coating 3 Film Build
Much thicker than standard coating systems
Requires design changes: re-analyze bores, sealing faces, O-ring grooves, and shaft clearances. Mask bonding surfaces and fastener seats.
Why not coating 5?
Identical ASTM performance to coating 3 and better than coating 12 at low film build, but roller-applied. Does not scale or meet the Flux aesthetics spec. Only consider if a spray-application route is possible
Corrosion Conclusions and Next Steps
Coating selection was the dominant factor. AC stray current during charging is a confirmed secondary contributor. Bonding is not implicated.
Adopt the galvanic isolator
Low cost, no downside identified, large reductions in AC stray current measured on two boats.
Qualify new coating options
Run tolerance analysis against known dry-film thicknesses and consult suppliers on cost.
Coatings are ranked by visual standards
The ASTM standards were the key factor in differentiating coating performance. Electrochemical methods were only able to disqualify one coating.
Testing continues
Coupons remain in immersion with the stainless hardware removed for further visual breakdown.